Guest Columns

Perspective:
Dairy Manufacturing

Your next line needs steam. Your boiler room might not be ready

Garrett Trapnell

Garrett Trapnell is founder and owner of Trap Energy Solutions in Shakopee, Minnesota, which designs and supplies steam systems for food and dairy processors across the Upper Midwest.

The dairy industry is in a building cycle. The International Dairy Foods Association counts more than $15 billion in planned processing investment across 85+ projects through 2030, with Wisconsin at $1.4 billion and Iowa at $701 million among the top five states. In this region, much of it is cheese, whey and powder, which are the most steam-hungry products a plant makes. New evaporators, dryers and whey lines are planned or underway from Muscoda to Lake Norden to Morris.

Most of these projects are expansions into boiler rooms sized for yesterday’s milk intake. That makes steam one of the first decisions to get boxed in, and one of the easiest to get wrong.

• The trouble with adding one big boiler

The traditional answer is one more large firetube or watertube boiler, sized for the post-expansion peak. In an expansion, that has four problems:

• Room — A large boiler needs floor space, height, a tube-pull area and often a new stack. Many dairy boiler rooms have none of these to spare, which pushes the project into a building addition.

• Lead time — Large custom boilers can take a year or more to arrive, and that easily becomes the critical path for a line that is otherwise ready to run.

• Turndown — Dairy steam load swings hard: CIP peaks, dryer starts, weekend lows. A boiler sized for the peak spends most of its hours at low fire, where efficiency drops, frequent cycling wears the equipment and the burner is prone to sooting.

• Redundancy — Covering a planned or unplanned outage of one large unit usually means a second large unit sitting idle, or a rental boiler parked outside.

• Building steam in modules

A modular plant meets the same load with several smaller, low-water-volume boilers under one master controller. The controller brings units on and off as demand moves, so each running unit stays near its efficient firing rate.

For an expansion, that changes the math:

• Add capacity in steps that match the project. Phase one gets two modules; phase two adds a third. Capital follows production instead of running ahead of it.

• Fit the space you have. Compact units often fit into an existing boiler room or a small addition, skipping the new building.

• Get steam faster. Standard modules ship faster than a large custom boiler. Low water volume means a cold start takes minutes, not hours.

• Redundancy is built in. With N+1 modules, losing one unit costs a fraction of capacity, not the plant.

• Taking it further: Put the steam where the load is

Decentralizing goes one step further. Instead of one central plant feeding long steam and condensate runs, modules sit near the processes they serve: one set by the dryer, another by the cheese make room. Shorter distribution means lower line losses, fewer traps to maintain and less condensate lost. It also means each area can have its own pressure, instead of running the whole plant at the highest pressure any one user needs.

• The staffing question

Licensed boiler operators are among the hardest people for a rural plant to hire, and the steam plant’s design decides how many you need.

Minnesota is the sharpest case. It is the only state in the region with a statewide attendance rule. Under Minn. R. 5225.1180, a plant over 500 state horsepower (total heating surface in square feet divided by 10) needs a licensed operator in constant attendance, which means carrying a full licensed crew. From 51 to 500 state horsepower, a licensed operator must check the plant at least every two hours. Iowa, the Dakotas and Wisconsin have no statewide attendance requirement, though some cities, such as Milwaukee, set their own rules.

Minnesota also offers a way out that few processors know about: the Unoccupied Boiler Plant provision (Minn. R. 5225.1180, subpart 5). With the state’s Department of Labor and Industry (DLI) approval, a plant can run with one in-person check per day if it meets the rule’s conditions. The plant must total 51 to 500 state horsepower, and DLI currently requires a standalone, unoccupied boiler building. Monitoring is electronic: Alarms, shutdowns and live video watch the plant around the clock and call out a licensed engineer when something needs attention. Because state horsepower counts heating surface, not output, a low-water-volume design can put roughly 3,000 boiler horsepower under the 500 state horsepower limit. Boiler choice matters here, because a low-water-volume boiler holds a fraction of the stored energy of a conventional firetube. A new high-pressure plant at a Minnesota cheese plant already runs this way.

For a Minnesota processor deciding whether the next line goes in at home or across the border, that removes one of the reasons to leave.

• Where modular doesn’t fit

Very large, steady base loads can favor a big watertube boiler with an economizer, and plants burning biomass or waste fuels need a boiler built for that fuel. Low-water-volume boilers also demand good feedwater treatment, with less margin for scale. Run the comparison before the boiler room is designed, not after.

Five questions to ask before your next expansion:

• What will the new line add to peak steam and to average steam, and how far apart are they?
• How much headroom does the existing boiler room really have, including redundancy?
• Can new capacity go in the existing room, or does it force a building addition?
• What is the boiler lead time, and is it on the project’s critical path?
• How many licensed operators will the finished plant need, and can you hire them where the plant is?

The right steam plant comes from answering those questions early. A line can be ready to run and still wait months on its boiler.

CMN

The views expressed by CMN’s guest columnists are their own opinions and do not necessarily reflect those of Cheese Market News®.

© 2026 Cheese Market News • Quarne Publishing, LLC • Legal Information • Online Privacy Policy • Terms and Conditions
Cheese Market News • Business/Advertising Office: P.O. Box 24 • Sun Prairie, WI 53590 • 608/831-6002
Cheese Market News • Editorial Office: 5315 Wall Street, Suite 100 • Madison, WI 53718 • 608/288-9090